Co-reporter:Rachel H. Gilmore;Mark C. Weidman;Elizabeth M. Y. Lee;William A. Tisdale
Nano Letters February 8, 2017 Volume 17(Issue 2) pp:893-901
Publication Date(Web):January 19, 2017
DOI:10.1021/acs.nanolett.6b04201
Energetic disorder in quantum dot solids adversely impacts charge carrier transport in quantum dot solar cells and electronic devices. Here, we use ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy to show that homogeneously broadened PbS quantum dot arrays (σhom2:σinh2 > 19:1, σinh/kBT < 0.4) can be realized if quantum dot batches are sufficiently monodisperse (δ ≲ 3.3%). The homogeneous line width is found to be an inverse function of quantum dot size, monotonically increasing from ∼25 meV for the largest quantum dots (5.8 nm diameter/0.92 eV energy) to ∼55 meV for the smallest (4.1 nm/1.3 eV energy). Furthermore, we show that intrinsic charge carrier hopping rates are faster for smaller quantum dots. This finding is the opposite of the mobility trend commonly observed in device measurements but is consistent with theoretical predictions. Fitting our data to a kinetic Monte Carlo model, we extract charge carrier hopping times ranging from 80 ps for the smallest quantum dots to over 1 ns for the largest, with the same ethanethiol ligand treatment. Additionally, we make the surprising observation that, in slightly polydisperse (δ ≲ 4%) quantum dot solids, structural disorder has a greater impact than energetic disorder in inhibiting charge carrier transport. These findings emphasize how small improvements in batch size dispersity can have a dramatic impact on intrinsic charge carrier hopping behavior and will stimulate further improvements in quantum dot device performance.Keywords: disorder; inhomogeneous broadening; Nanocrystal; transport; ultrafast;
Co-reporter:Liang Shi, Chee Kong Lee and Adam P. Willard
ACS Central Science December 27, 2017 Volume 3(Issue 12) pp:1262-1262
Publication Date(Web):December 12, 2017
DOI:10.1021/acscentsci.7b00404
The dissociation of excited electron–hole pairs is a microscopic process that is fundamental to the performance of photovoltaic systems. For this process to be successful, the oppositely charged electron and hole must overcome an electrostatic binding energy before they undergo ground state recombination. It has been observed previously that the presence of energetic disorder can lead to a reduction in recombination losses. Here we investigate this effect using a simple model of charge dynamics at a donor–acceptor interface. We consider the effect of spatial variations in electronic energy levels, such as those that arise in disordered molecular systems, on dissociation yield and demonstrate that it is maximized with a finite amount of disorder. We demonstrate that this is a nonequilibrium effect that is mediated by the dissipation driven formation of partially dissociated intermediate states that are long-lived because they cannot easily recombine. We present a kinetic model that incorporates these states and show that it is capable of reproducing similar behavior when it is parametrized with nonequilibrium rates.
Co-reporter:John A. Kattirtzi;David T. Limmer
PNAS 2017 114 (51 ) pp:13374-13379
Publication Date(Web):2017-12-19
DOI:10.1073/pnas.1700093114
We have used molecular simulation and methods of importance sampling to study the thermodynamics and kinetics of ionic charge
separation at a liquid water–metal interface. We have considered this process using canonical examples of two different classes
of ions: a simple alkali–halide pair, Na+I−, or classical ions, and the products of water autoionization, H3O+OH−, or water ions. We find that for both ion classes, the microscopic mechanism of charge separation, including water’s collective
role in the process, is conserved between the bulk liquid and the electrode interface. However, the thermodynamic and kinetic
details of the process differ between these two environments in a way that depends on ion type. In the case of the classical
ion pairs, a higher free-energy barrier to charge separation and a smaller flux over that barrier at the interface result
in a rate of dissociation that is 40 times slower relative to the bulk. For water ions, a slightly higher free-energy barrier
is offset by a higher flux over the barrier from longer lived hydrogen-bonding patterns at the interface, resulting in a rate
of association that is similar both at and away from the interface. We find that these differences in rates and stabilities
of charge separation are due to the altered ability of water to solvate and reorganize in the vicinity of the metal interface.
Co-reporter:John A. Kattirtzi;David T. Limmer
PNAS 2017 114 (51 ) pp:13374-13379
Publication Date(Web):2017-12-19
DOI:10.1073/pnas.1700093114
We have used molecular simulation and methods of importance sampling to study the thermodynamics and kinetics of ionic charge
separation at a liquid water–metal interface. We have considered this process using canonical examples of two different classes
of ions: a simple alkali–halide pair, Na+I−, or classical ions, and the products of water autoionization, H3O+OH−, or water ions. We find that for both ion classes, the microscopic mechanism of charge separation, including water’s collective
role in the process, is conserved between the bulk liquid and the electrode interface. However, the thermodynamic and kinetic
details of the process differ between these two environments in a way that depends on ion type. In the case of the classical
ion pairs, a higher free-energy barrier to charge separation and a smaller flux over that barrier at the interface result
in a rate of dissociation that is 40 times slower relative to the bulk. For water ions, a slightly higher free-energy barrier
is offset by a higher flux over the barrier from longer lived hydrogen-bonding patterns at the interface, resulting in a rate
of association that is similar both at and away from the interface. We find that these differences in rates and stabilities
of charge separation are due to the altered ability of water to solvate and reorganize in the vicinity of the metal interface.
Co-reporter:John A. Kattirtzi;David T. Limmer
PNAS 2017 114 (51 ) pp:13374-13379
Publication Date(Web):2017-12-19
DOI:10.1073/pnas.1700093114
We have used molecular simulation and methods of importance sampling to study the thermodynamics and kinetics of ionic charge
separation at a liquid water–metal interface. We have considered this process using canonical examples of two different classes
of ions: a simple alkali–halide pair, Na+I−, or classical ions, and the products of water autoionization, H3O+OH−, or water ions. We find that for both ion classes, the microscopic mechanism of charge separation, including water’s collective
role in the process, is conserved between the bulk liquid and the electrode interface. However, the thermodynamic and kinetic
details of the process differ between these two environments in a way that depends on ion type. In the case of the classical
ion pairs, a higher free-energy barrier to charge separation and a smaller flux over that barrier at the interface result
in a rate of dissociation that is 40 times slower relative to the bulk. For water ions, a slightly higher free-energy barrier
is offset by a higher flux over the barrier from longer lived hydrogen-bonding patterns at the interface, resulting in a rate
of association that is similar both at and away from the interface. We find that these differences in rates and stabilities
of charge separation are due to the altered ability of water to solvate and reorganize in the vicinity of the metal interface.
Co-reporter:John A. Kattirtzi;David T. Limmer
PNAS 2017 114 (51 ) pp:13374-13379
Publication Date(Web):2017-12-19
DOI:10.1073/pnas.1700093114
We have used molecular simulation and methods of importance sampling to study the thermodynamics and kinetics of ionic charge
separation at a liquid water–metal interface. We have considered this process using canonical examples of two different classes
of ions: a simple alkali–halide pair, Na+I−, or classical ions, and the products of water autoionization, H3O+OH−, or water ions. We find that for both ion classes, the microscopic mechanism of charge separation, including water’s collective
role in the process, is conserved between the bulk liquid and the electrode interface. However, the thermodynamic and kinetic
details of the process differ between these two environments in a way that depends on ion type. In the case of the classical
ion pairs, a higher free-energy barrier to charge separation and a smaller flux over that barrier at the interface result
in a rate of dissociation that is 40 times slower relative to the bulk. For water ions, a slightly higher free-energy barrier
is offset by a higher flux over the barrier from longer lived hydrogen-bonding patterns at the interface, resulting in a rate
of association that is similar both at and away from the interface. We find that these differences in rates and stabilities
of charge separation are due to the altered ability of water to solvate and reorganize in the vicinity of the metal interface.
Co-reporter:Chee Kong Lee; Liang Shi
The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2016 Volume 7(Issue 12) pp:2246-2251
Publication Date(Web):May 30, 2016
DOI:10.1021/acs.jpclett.6b00871
In this Letter, we explore how the microscopic dynamics of charge-transfer (CT) excitons are influenced by the presence of an external magnetic field in disordered molecular semiconductors. This influence is driven by the dynamic interplay between the spin and spatial degrees of freedom of the electron–hole pair. To account for this interplay, we have developed a numerical framework that combines a traditional model of quantum spin dynamics with a stochastic coarse-grained model of charge transport. This combination provides a general and efficient methodology for simulating the effects of magnetic field on CT state dynamics, therefore providing a basis for revealing the microscopic origin of experimentally observed magnetic field effects. We demonstrate that simulations carried out on our model are capable of reproducing experimental results as well as generating theoretical predictions related to the efficiency of organic electronic materials.
Co-reporter:Elizabeth M. Y. Lee, William A. Tisdale, and Adam P. Willard
The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2015 Volume 119(Issue 30) pp:9501-9509
Publication Date(Web):June 24, 2015
DOI:10.1021/acs.jpcb.5b01886
Recent experiments aimed at probing the dynamics of excitons have revealed that semiconducting films composed of disordered molecular subunits, unlike expectations for their perfectly ordered counterparts, can exhibit a time-dependent diffusivity in which the effective early time diffusion constant is larger than that of the steady state. This observation has led to speculation about what role, if any, microscopic disorder may play in enhancing exciton transport properties. In this article, we present the results of a model study aimed at addressing this point. Specifically, we introduce a general model, based upon Förster theory, for incoherent exciton diffusion in a material composed of independent molecular subunits with static energetic disorder. Energetic disorder leads to heterogeneity in molecule-to-molecule transition rates, which we demonstrate has two important consequences related to exciton transport. First, the distribution of local site-specific hopping rates is broadened in a manner that results in a decrease in average exciton diffusivity relative to that in a perfectly ordered film. Second, since excitons prefer to make transitions that are downhill in energy, the steady state distribution of exciton energies is biased toward low-energy molecular subunits, those that exhibit reduced diffusivity relative to a perfectly ordered film. These effects combine to reduce the net diffusivity in a manner that is time dependent and grows more pronounced as disorder is increased. Notably, however, we demonstrate that the presence of energetic disorder can give rise to a population of molecular subunits with exciton transfer rates exceeding those of subunits in an energetically uniform material. Such enhancements may play an important role in processes that are sensitive to molecular-scale fluctuations in exciton density field.